[NetBehaviour] Fwd: Turbulence.org Going Offline 12/31/16

[Pall Thayer]

---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Pall Thayer <pallthay at gmail.com>
Date: Sun, May 8, 2016 at 9:24 PM
Subject: Re: Turbulence.org Going Offline 12/31/16
To: Annette Weintraub <weintraub at ccny.cuny.edu>, New Radio and Performing
Arts Inc. <newradio.org at gmail.com>
Cc: abelinkoln at linkoln.net <abelinkoln at linkoln.net>, adam at yamanakanash.net <
adam at yamanakanash.net>, atrowbridge at saic.edu <atrowbridge at saic.edu>,
aasilva at ncsu.edu <aasilva at ncsu.edu>, artvideoKOELN at gmail.com <
artvideoKOELN at gmail.com>, info at aihasegawa.info <info at aihasegawa.info>,
raphael at raphaeladjani.com <raphael at raphaeladjani.com>, akito at media.mit.edu <
akito at media.mit.edu>, nav.reyort at gmail.com <nav.reyort at gmail.com>,
author at webyarns.com <author at webyarns.com>, sondheim at panix.com <
sondheim at panix.com>, a.ludovico at neural.it <a.ludovico at neural.it>,
galloway at nyu.edu <galloway at nyu.edu>, webmaster at easylife.org <
webmaster at easylife.org>, alimiharbi at gmail.com <alimiharbi at gmail.com>,
aparrish at nyu.edu <aparrish at nyu.edu>, a at pitaru.com <a at pitaru.com>,
ajalexander at ucsd.edu <ajalexander at ucsd.edu>, andrea at andreapolli.com <
andrea at andreapolli.com>, a.andreas at nictoglobe.com <a.andreas at nictoglobe.com>,
Andrew Lyman <andrewtlyman at gmail.com>, deck at artcontext.org <
deck at artcontext.org>, eng_angie at yahoo.com <eng_angie at yahoo.com>,
missanitafontaine at gmail.com <missanitafontaine at gmail.com>,
a.munster at unsw.edu.au <a.munster at unsw.edu.au>, anna.pinkas at gmail.com <
anna.pinkas at gmail.com>, anne.galloway at vuw.ac.nz <anne.galloway at vuw.ac.nz>,
anne.helmond at gmail.com <anne.helmond at gmail.com>, Annie Abrahams <
bram.org at gmail.com>, as at gratin.org <as at gratin.org>, james at factorynoir.com <
james at factorynoir.com>, info at ataut.net <info at ataut.net>, aya at technekai.com <
aya at technekai.com>, barbara at 1001.net.au <barbara at 1001.net.au>,
threads at wildernesspuppets.net <threads at wildernesspuppets.net>, Belen Gache <
belengache at gmail.com>, benjamin.dean at aya.yale.edu <
benjamin.dean at aya.yale.edu>, recyclism at gmail.com <recyclism at gmail.com>,
ben at benjaminrosenbaum.com <ben at benjaminrosenbaum.com>, bcb at benton-c.com <
bcb at benton-c.com>, dlhchew at gmail.com <dlhchew at gmail.com>,
matthew.gaffney at dailymotion.com <matthew.gaffney at dailymotion.com>,
maximilianoferro at hotmail.com <maximilianoferro at hotmail.com>,
intimaci at gmail.com <intimaci at gmail.com>, bkligerman at gmail.com <
bkligerman at gmail.com>, brendah555 at gmail.com <brendah555 at gmail.com>,
brian_stefans at brown.edu <brian_stefans at brown.edu>, evolutie at gmail.com <
evolutie at gmail.com>, Brooke Knight <brooke_knight at emerson.edu>,
brooke at bsing.net <brooke at bsing.net>, arikan at burak-arikan.com <
arikan at burak-arikan.com>, zanni.org at gmail.com <zanni.org at gmail.com>,
carmin at pixelyze.com <carmin at pixelyze.com>, contact at carolekim.com <
contact at carolekim.com>, Cary Peppermint <capeppermint at gmail.com>,
heilmancc at gmail.com <heilmancc at gmail.com>, cat at microrevolt.org <
cat at microrevolt.org>, info at chitraganesh.com <info at chitraganesh.com>,
caeics at rit.edu <caeics at rit.edu>, chrsmnn at gmail.com <chrsmnn at gmail.com>,
christopher.salter at concordia.ca <christopher.salter at concordia.ca>,
xn at xncroft.com <xn at xncroft.com>, paulc at newschool.edu <paulc at newschool.edu>,
christina at christinamcphee.net <christina at christinamcphee.net>, xtine at rcn.com
<xtine at rcn.com>, claudia at puncture.org <claudia at puncture.org>, ctgr at free.fr <
ctgr at free.fr>, cory.arcangel at gmail.com <cory.arcangel at gmail.com>, Curt
Cloninger <curt at lab404.com>, post at dafna.info <post at dafna.info>,
damali at damaliayo.com <damali at damaliayo.com>, Dan Phiffer <dan at phiffer.org>,
dlk253 at nyu.edu <dlk253 at nyu.edu>, dane at eatmydata.co.uk <dane at eatmydata.co.uk>,
daniel at rednoise.org <daniel at rednoise.org>, ddacosta at endicott.edu <
ddacosta at endicott.edu>, dgd at cs.brown.edu <dgd at cs.brown.edu>, dgolds at yorku.ca
<dgolds at yorku.ca>, jhave2 at gmail.com <jhave2 at gmail.com>, davidart at gmail.com <
davidart at gmail.com>, dmiller at curry.edu <dmiller at curry.edu>, self at evident.com
<self at evident.com>, info at geuzen.org <info at geuzen.org>, Diane Bertolo <
diane at panix.com>, duras at thing.net <duras at thing.net>, d at computerfinearts.com
<d at computerfinearts.com>, Douglas Gast <dgast at tricity.wsu.edu>,
douglas at music.columbia.edu <douglas at music.columbia.edu>, drx at a-blast.org <
drx at a-blast.org>, drew.baker at kcl.ac.uk <drew.baker at kcl.ac.uk>,
dharry at media.mit.edu <dharry at media.mit.edu>, Leila Christine Nadir <
lcnadir at gmail.com>, edwardpotter at gmail.com <edwardpotter at gmail.com>,
eduardo at navasse.net <eduardo at navasse.net>, mail at eitherormusic.org <
mail at eitherormusic.org>, e at activesurface.com <e at activesurface.com>,
ehorwatt at gmail.com <ehorwatt at gmail.com>, elikeszler at gmail.com <
elikeszler at gmail.com>, emiliepitoiset at gmail.com <emiliepitoiset at gmail.com>,
hatfield.es at gmail.com <hatfield.es at gmail.com>, eric_gordon at emerson.edu <
eric_gordon at emerson.edu>, ehreha at chatham-nj.org <ehreha at chatham-nj.org>,
eric.laska at gmail.com <eric.laska at gmail.com>, eriel at modistudio.com <
eriel at modistudio.com>, eric at schefteredit.com <eric at schefteredit.com>,
belgu003 at umn.edu <belgu003 at umn.edu>, eryk.salvaggio at gmail.com <
eryk.salvaggio at gmail.com>, e.kosmatopoulos at gmail.com <
e.kosmatopoulos at gmail.com>, Ethan Ham <ethan at ethanham.com>,
eugene.thacker at lcc.gatech.edu <eugene.thacker at lcc.gatech.edu>,
evann at evannsiebens.com <evann at evannsiebens.com>, contact at davejimison.com <
contact at davejimison.com>, michi at arteco.org <michi at arteco.org>,
sera at fhwang.net <sera at fhwang.net>, Frank Marchese <fmarchese at pace.edu>,
contact at cestdelart.org <contact at cestdelart.org>, fp at friederikepaetzold.com <
fp at friederikepaetzold.com>, fiezi at zeitbrand.net <fiezi at zeitbrand.net>,
writingcenter at utulsa.edu <writingcenter at utulsa.edu>, G.H. Hovagimyan <
ghh at thing.net>, fille at nibewege.org <fille at nibewege.org>,
genekoo at post.harvard.edu <genekoo at post.harvard.edu>,
kiss at geoffreylillemon.com <kiss at geoffreylillemon.com>, gthoma at artic.edu <
gthoma at artic.edu>, g at trembl.org <g at trembl.org>, g at studiotimo.com <
g at studiotimo.com>, golan at flong.com <golan at flong.com>, glue at ufl.edu <
glue at ufl.edu>, contact at chatonsky.net <contact at chatonsky.net>,
INFO at greyworld.org <INFO at greyworld.org>, haeyoungk at earthlink.net <
haeyoungk at earthlink.net>, hal at gertstein.org <hal at gertstein.org>,
hcs at productmsd.com <hcs at productmsd.com>, Helen Thorington <
helen.thorington at gmail.com>, intima.org at gmail.com <intima.org at gmail.com>,
kanarinka at ikatun.com <kanarinka at ikatun.com>, carpenter at luckysoap.com <
carpenter at luckysoap.com>, Jason Freeman <jason at jasonfreeman.net>, Jason
Nelson <heliopod at gmail.com>, Jason Rohrer <jasonrohrer at fastmail.fm>,
jason at smileproject.com <jason at smileproject.com>, magic at inch.com <
magic at inch.com>, info at drame.org <info at drame.org>, jefftimesten at gmail.com <
jefftimesten at gmail.com>, mail at jeffreythompson.org <mail at jeffreythompson.org>,
jenrmeagher at gmail.com <jenrmeagher at gmail.com>, info at jennylin.net <
info at jennylin.net>, j at jesperjuul.net <j at jesperjuul.net>, jess at rssgallery.com
<jess at rssgallery.com>, Jesse Gilbert <jessegilbert at gmail.com>,
jwestbrook1 at saic.edu <jwestbrook1 at saic.edu>, Jillian Mcdonald <
jmcdonald at jillianmcdonald.net>, jim at vispo.com <jim at vispo.com>,
info at subtone-concerts.de <info at subtone-concerts.de>, Jo-Anne Green <
jogjoburg at gmail.com>, jzellen at gmail.com <jzellen at gmail.com>,
joed at mfaca.sva.edu <joed at mfaca.sva.edu>, info at treib-stoff.com <
info at treib-stoff.com>, cabralj at gmail.com <cabralj at gmail.com>,
John_Cayley at brown.edu <John_Cayley at brown.edu>,
john_craig_freeman at emerson.edu <john_craig_freeman at emerson.edu>,
jhudak at pobox.com <jhudak at pobox.com>, John Klima <klima at echonyc.com>, John
Neilson <jneil at echonyc.com>, john_priestley at verizon.net <
john_priestley at verizon.net>, jroach at speakeasy.net <jroach at speakeasy.net>,
jfsjr at numeral.com <jfsjr at numeral.com>, snavely at mit.edu <snavely at mit.edu>,
jonah at coin-operated.com <jonah at coin-operated.com>, jdf at pobox.com <
jdf at pobox.com>, jordan.t.paul at gmail.com <jordan.t.paul at gmail.com>,
email at jornebner.info <email at jornebner.info>, Joseph Lefèvre <
joseph at sat.qc.ca>, Joe Moore <moore.joseph at gmail.com>, jesis at xs4all.nl <
jesis at xs4all.nl>, julia at juliachristensen.com <julia at juliachristensen.com>,
steinmetz at nyu.edu <steinmetz at nyu.edu>, info at nearfuturelaboratory.com <
info at nearfuturelaboratory.com>, Kate Armstrong <katearmstrong at gmail.com>,
kb at katherinebehar.com <kb at katherinebehar.com>, kv2157 at columbia.edu <
kv2157 at columbia.edu>, Kenneth at tinkin.com <Kenneth at tinkin.com>,
kham at illinois.edu <kham at illinois.edu>, kurt.ralske at gmail.com <
kurt.ralske at gmail.com>, me at kushaldave.com <me at kushaldave.com>,
info at liminalprojects.com <info at liminalprojects.com>, laurel at arcstudio.com <
laurel at arcstudio.com>, laurencornell at rhizome.org <laurencornell at rhizome.org>,
lsj at meotod.com <lsj at meotod.com>, figment at w----e.net <figment at w----e.net>,
lsolaas at gmail.com <lsolaas at gmail.com>, agitprop at lesliensinvisibles.org <
agitprop at lesliensinvisibles.org>, llacook at yahoo.com <llacook at yahoo.com>,
leejayxia at gmail.com <leejayxia at gmail.com>, chinacyberart at yahoo.com <
chinacyberart at yahoo.com>, l.vickery at ecu.edu.au <l.vickery at ecu.edu.au>,
efilardi at gmail.com <efilardi at gmail.com>, kg2007 at columbia.edu <
kg2007 at columbia.edu>, lovidlovid at gmail.com <lovidlovid at gmail.com>,
giraffe at easynet.co.uk <giraffe at easynet.co.uk>,
l.silva at kunsthalle-lissabon.org <l.silva at kunsthalle-lissabon.org>,
entity at 100luz.com.ar <entity at 100luz.com.ar>, maggi at mills.edu <
maggi at mills.edu>, maja at music.columbia.edu <maja at music.columbia.edu>,
maya at kalogera.net <maya at kalogera.net>, marc.garrett at furtherfield.org <
marc.garrett at furtherfield.org>, marcin at ramocki.net <marcin at ramocki.net>,
m.deseriis at neu.edu <m.deseriis at neu.edu>, mn at onair.co.za <mn at onair.co.za>,
margaretbellafiore at juno.com <margaretbellafiore at juno.com>, ioveva at gmail.com
<ioveva at gmail.com>, ghanimariam at hotmail.com <ghanimariam at hotmail.com>,
marianne at mrpetit.com <marianne at mrpetit.com>, marika at incident.net <
marika at incident.net>, mg_decoi at mit.edu <mg_decoi at mit.edu>, mc at itison.tv <
mc at itison.tv>, marta at martalwin.com <marta at martalwin.com>, martha at nmd.com.br
<martha at nmd.com.br>, w at bewitched.com <w at bewitched.com>, Martina Ruhsam <
martina.ruhsam at gmail.com>, nayuntuk at sympatico.ca <nayuntuk at sympatico.ca>,
martine at neddam.info <martine at neddam.info>, mary at maryflanagan.com <
mary at maryflanagan.com>, matt at sfsound.org <matt at sfsound.org>,
rogalsky at queensu.ca <rogalsky at queensu.ca>, Matthew Belanger <mb at fatbits.net>,
WarkK at newschool.edu <WarkK at newschool.edu>, gimmeeyoung at gmail.con
<gimmeeyoung at gmail.con>, mobadike at pratt.edu <mobadike at pratt.edu>, Michael
Mandiberg <michael at mandiberg.com>, mikemittelman at gmail.com <
mikemittelman at gmail.com>, m at takeo.org <m at takeo.org>, mike at tippett.org <
mike at tippett.org>, info at winklerwordart.com <info at winklerwordart.com>,
mocksim at gmail.com <mocksim at gmail.com>, michelle riel <michelleriel at gmail.com>,
misha at ubermatic.org <misha at ubermatic.org>, info at michaelmeida.org <
info at michaelmeida.org>, doutorsocratesoreidofutebol at gmail.com <
doutorsocratesoreidofutebol at gmail.com>, miyamasaoka at mindspring.com <
miyamasaoka at mindspring.com>, info at morganbarnard.com <info at morganbarnard.com>,
mouchette at mouchette.org <mouchette at mouchette.org>, Tim Whidden <
twhid at mteww.com>, Mushon Zer-Aviv <mushon at shual.com>, nana at nana.net <
nana at nana.net>, naomi.spellman at gmail.com <naomi.spellman at gmail.com>,
bookchin at gmail.com <bookchin at gmail.com>, nhalvers at yahoo.com <
nhalvers at yahoo.com>, hello at slanginternational.org <
hello at slanginternational.org>, nathaniel stern <nathaniel.stern at gmail.com>,
zusman at earthlink.net <zusman at earthlink.net>, nknouf at gmail.com <
nknouf at gmail.com>, nicholasobri at gmail.com <nicholasobri at gmail.com>,
nick at didkovsky.com <nick at didkovsky.com>, Nick Montfort <nickm at nickm.com>,
niclauss at flyingpuppet.com <niclauss at flyingpuppet.com>, ninasobell at gmail.com
<ninasobell at gmail.com>, NBavarsky at gmail.com <NBavarsky at gmail.com>,
nms277 at nyu.edu <nms277 at nyu.edu>, nwf at ucsd.edu <nwf at ucsd.edu>,
tutanur at gmail.com <tutanur at gmail.com>, olenhsu at hotmail.com <
olenhsu at hotmail.com>, O.Goriunova at warwick.ac.uk <O.Goriunova at warwick.ac.uk>,
omer at omta.co <omer at omta.co>, onome at thememorexe.com <onome at thememorexe.com>,
Norie Neumark <maria at out-of-sync.com>, pamelaz at pamelaz.com <
pamelaz at pamelaz.com>, info at paolocirio.net <info at paolocirio.net>,
paperrad at yahoo.com <paperrad at yahoo.com>, patricia at aestheticmanagement.com <
patricia at aestheticmanagement.com>, pl at voyd.com <pl at voyd.com>,
paul at paulcatanese.com <paul at paulcatanese.com>, djspooky at sozomedia.com <
djspooky at sozomedia.com>, paul.slocum at gmail.com <paul.slocum at gmail.com>,
petegomes at gmail.com <petegomes at gmail.com>, peterbrinson at gmail.com <
peterbrinson at gmail.com>, oxygen at 6168.org <oxygen at 6168.org>,
peter at luining.com <peter at luining.com>, pmt4u at virginia.edu <
pmt4u at virginia.edu>, drmoth at tpg.com.au <drmoth at tpg.com.au>, prema at thing.net
<prema at thing.net>, manyarrowsmusic at gmail.com <manyarrowsmusic at gmail.com>,
luke at music.columbia.edu <luke at music.columbia.edu>, reiner at reiner-strasser.de
<reiner at reiner-strasser.de>, reynald.drouhin at gmail.com <
reynald.drouhin at gmail.com>, ricardo at ambriente.com <ricardo at ambriente.com>,
rstreit at gmail.com <rstreit at gmail.com>, rms at gnu.org <rms at gnu.org>,
info at dividedbyxero.com <info at dividedbyxero.com>, kendall at wordcircuits.com <
kendall at wordcircuits.com>, rjo218 at gmail.com <rjo218 at gmail.com>,
rochfor at o2.pl <rochfor at o2.pl>, info at cage.nl <info at cage.nl>,
ryan.griffis at gmail.com <ryan.griffis at gmail.com>, sawako at troncolon.com <
sawako at troncolon.com>, jeannejo at usc.edu <jeannejo at usc.edu>, scotgl at gmail.com
<scotgl at gmail.com>, Scott Kildall <scott at kildall.com>, sriley2 at gmail.com <
sriley2 at gmail.com>, info at shannonkennedy.net <info at shannonkennedy.net>,
shelley at shelleyhirsch.com <shelley at shelleyhirsch.com>, laurentz at uol.com.br <
laurentz at uol.com.br>, simon at littlepig.org.uk <simon at littlepig.org.uk>,
sonyaa at cs.cmu.edu <sonyaa at cs.cmu.edu>, sophia at sophiabrueckner.com <
sophia at sophiabrueckner.com>, Stanza <Stanza at sublime.net>,
stephan at oddnoise.com <stephan at oddnoise.com>, info at pan-o-matic.com <
info at pan-o-matic.com>, Stephanie Vella <svella at ccny.cuny.edu>, Steve Dietz <
stevedietz at yproductions.com>, Steve Klise <sk at skli.se>, steve at visitsteve.com
<steve at visitsteve.com>, stevenevanlam at gmail.com <stevenevanlam at gmail.com>,
tal at talhalpern.org <tal at talhalpern.org>, tarazee at gmail.com <
tarazee at gmail.com>, t3db0t at gmail.com <t3db0t at gmail.com>, terirueb at gmail.com
<terirueb at gmail.com>, Thalia_Field at brown.edu <Thalia_Field at brown.edu>,
thomas.asmuth at gmail.com <thomas.asmuth at gmail.com>, info at automatedbeacon.net
<info at automatedbeacon.net>, tim at perkis.com <tim at perkis.com>,
avatar at tinalaporta.net <avatar at tinalaporta.net>, tobias at quadrantcrossing.org
<tobias at quadrantcrossing.org>, todd at toddreynolds.com <todd at toddreynolds.com>,
Tom Igoe <tom.igoe at nyu.edu>, tplsek at berklee.edu <tplsek at berklee.edu>,
trebor at thing.net <trebor at thing.net>, troy at iconica.org <troy at iconica.org>,
play at ubermorgen.com <play at ubermorgen.com>, ulises.mejias at oswego.edu <
ulises.mejias at oswego.edu>, Ursula Endlicher <ue at ursenal.net>,
usman at haque.co.uk <usman at haque.co.uk>, victor at n-gon.com <victor at n-gon.com>,
toria at redhotcoil.com <toria at redhotcoil.com>,
postmaster at amsterdameditions.com <postmaster at amsterdameditions.com>,
Vivian.selbo at nyu.edu <Vivian.selbo at nyu.edu>, wjamesau at well.com <
wjamesau at well.com>, info at earsay.org <info at earsay.org>, Will Pappenheimer <
wpappenheimer at pace.edu>, Willy Whip <willywhip at no-log.org>,
woody at deadceo.com <woody at deadceo.com>, xpehuet at gmail.com <xpehuet at gmail.com>,
hakantopal at gmail.com <hakantopal at gmail.com>, Yael Kanarek <
yael at treasurecrumbs.com>, abbas.yasmine at gmail.com <abbas.yasmine at gmail.com>,
info at yoavgal.com <info at yoavgal.com>, y at c505.com <y at c505.com>, Yotam Mann <
yotammann at gmail.com>, tfa at chollian.net <tfa at chollian.net>,
yury at mybeatingheart.com <yury at mybeatingheart.com>, zachlayton at gmail.com <
zachlayton at gmail.com>, zannah marsh <zannah.m at gmail.com>,
zeena at zeenaparkins.com <zeena at zeenaparkins.com>, zoe at zoebeloff.com <
zoe at zoebeloff.com>, Muthi Reed <freethelandcooperative at gmail.com>


Hello all,

When I recieved the email from Turbulence.org, that they would be
suspending operations at the end of this year, I immediately posted notice
to the netbehaviour email list. I have to say that I'm a bit disappointed
in the reaction there and here. Most people have responded in a way that
suggests that they appreciate what turbulence.org has done over the years
and seem to accept a notion that they have done marvelous work but that it
is now time to let it end. I don't agree. What turbulence.org has done is
to further the exploration of the internet and networks in general as an
art form. The notion that they have done what can be done would suggest
that this has now been fully explored and we've reached the end. This is
not the case. Losing turbulence.org means losing a platform that has
prompted continuous exploration into a very unique artform that is
constantly expanding. I agree that we have to find a way to archive what
Helen and Jo have done but we also need to find a way to continue their
work. We're not done.

Best r.
Pall Thayer

On Sun, May 8, 2016 at 8:55 PM Annette Weintraub <weintraub at ccny.cuny.edu>
wrote:

> Helen and Jo,
>
> It’s been an extraordinary run. Thanks for your dedication to net art in
> all its forms, your hard work to keep this going as long as it has, and for
> your continuing support.
>
> 20 years in Net Art is an aeon!
>
> Warmly,
> Annette
>
> Annette Weintraub
> annette at annetteweintraub.com
>
>
>
> On May 7, 2016, at 2:17 PM, New Radio and Performing Arts Inc. <
> newradio.org at gmail.com> wrote:
>
> Dear Turbulence.org Artist/Friend,
>
> After an extraordinary 20-year run, NRPA co-directors Helen Thorington and
> Jo-Anne Green announce the end of the Turbulence.org project.
>
> Operating Support has steadily declined over the past decade, and has
> reached a point where it no longer sustains our involvement. We will go
> offline on December 31, 2016.
>
> If you need access to our server to obtain a copy of your files, please
> contact Helen at helen.thorington at gmail.com
>
> With warm wishes,
>
> Helen and Jo
> --
> Helen Thorington and Jo-Anne Green, Co-Directors
> New Radio and Performing Arts, Inc.
> http://new-radio.org
> http://turbulence.org
> http://somewhere.org
>
>
> Annette Weintraub
> annette at annetteweintraub.com
>
>
>
> Annette Weintraub
> annette at annetteweintraub.com
>
>
>
> --
P Thayer, Artist
http://pallthayer.dyndns.org
-- 
P Thayer, Artist
http://pallthayer.dyndns.org
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.netbehaviour.org/pipermail/netbehaviour/attachments/20160509/5da16a57/attachment.htm>