[NetBehaviour] Thoughts on Leonardo's St. Anne

Max Herman maxnmherman at hotmail.com
Sun Sep 20 00:02:26 CEST 2020

Hi all,

I spent some time today looking at Leonardo's Virgin and Child with Saint Anne in depth for the first time and got an idea of the following interpretation.

  1.  The landscape is very vertical, going from mountaintops to rivers to lakes or seas, then to earth with vegetation and finally crumbling pebbles at the bottom.
  2.  The background is therefore the macrocosm, high to low.
  3.  The people are a human landscape, also vertical.
  4.  Saint Anne is Mary's parent, the oldest and greatest, representing Nature.
  5.  Mary is the next largest figure, child of Anne, representing Experience/Esperienza, the same allegory as the ML.
  6.  The infant Jesus is the child and pupil of Experience, which is to say, the artist or human/divine hybrid, the present-time being.
  7.  The still-infant artist/scientist/human agent is beating up on the lamb, mishandling it.
  8.  The lamb represents the lowest level of power (innocence, suffering, sacrifice, time, mortality, opportunity, life as such).
  9.  Experience is the guide, parent, instructor, and guardian of the artist, and pulls the child back from their rashness.
  10. The disobedient artist doesn't really want to obey, but is weaker than the parent and therefore does.
  11. Nature looks over all, calm and interested but also disengaged, crowned with the vortices that drive all processes that traverse across levels.
  12. The sequences are therefore cyclical, like a linear loop or feedback system, within both the natural and the human cosmos.

I haven't cross-checked it yet with Leonardo experts and it could be total BS (so it is offered with a grain of salt in the spirit of poetic license) but it derives somewhat from Leonardo's words:

"If you condemn painting, which is the only imitator of all visible works of nature, you will certainly despise a subtle invention which brings philosophy and subtle speculation to the consideration of the nature of all forms — seas and plains, trees, animals, plants and flowers — which are surrounded by shade and light. And this is true knowledge and the legitimate issue of nature; for painting is born of nature — or, to speak more correctly, we will say it is the grandchild of nature; for all visible things are produced by nature, and these her children have given birth to painting. Hence we may justly call it the grandchild of nature and related to God."

"Experience, the interpreter between formative nature and the human race, teaches how that nature acts among mortals; and being constrained by necessity cannot act otherwise than as reason, which is its helm, requires her to act."

Leonardo may have imagined after painting the Saint Anne something different than the verticality and hierarchy, having more unity and subtle interfusion of elements, more cyclicality and less architecture, leading to the more spherical and flowing cosmos of the later "universal picture" the Mona Lisa which is also an allegory of Experience.


All best wishes,


-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.netbehaviour.org/pipermail/netbehaviour/attachments/20200919/aefb8f14/attachment.htm>

More information about the NetBehaviour mailing list